No ‘Woke 2.0,’ and Vance makes an early move

The Briefing, Vol. XIV, Issue 45

This week:

  • Vance makes the first move by faulting the Iran War
  • Silver linings of 2026
  • No “Woke 2.0”

Outlook

Republicans have now lost what had seemed a safe Senate seat in Mississippi, as Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith (R) went down to defeat to Democrat Scott Colom (D). Things are also not looking good in the only remaining uncalled race for Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-Alaska). Former Rep. Mary Peltola (D) could be declared the winner in that contest this week before or after ranked choices are factored in. She has already declared victory and is just on the cup of 50 percent.

This would bring the total Democratic gain in the U.S. Senate to nine seats — the same number Republicans gained in their 2014 blowout in President Barack Obama’s second term. At that time, the result seemed to presage a bright post-Obama future for the Republican Party as it then existed. Donald Trump’s rise complicated that future, but it did not prevent Republican victory in the presidential election that followed.

So can Democrats look forward with such hopes? The historic trends favor them. After a re-elected president’s party loses in the midterm, the party out of power usually regains the presidency in the next election. This happened after wave-like second-midterm wins in 1950, 1958, 1966, 1974, 2006, and 2014, and it also happened in 1998, when Republicans didn’t get much of a wave, breaking even in the Senate and losing a few House seats.

The one modern exception was 1986, when President Ronald Reagan’s Republicans received a modest shellacking, losing eight Senate seats but only a handful of seats in the U.S. House. After that, Vice President George H.W. Bush went on to win the 1988 presidential election decisively over a weak Democratic nominee.

Vice President JD Vance would, of course, love to follow that track and succeed his boss as president directly through a presidential election. But this has been exceedingly rare, happening only four times in our nation’s history and only once (Bush himself) since 1837. Vice Presidents have been much more likely to reach the presidency due to death or resignation than through post-election transfers of power from their former boss.

The bigger problem for Vance, of course, is that the magnitude of this year’s election loss has people questioning the future direction of the party. We noted several times that Trump’s legacy would be on the ballot — and he said something similar. If voters rendered such a negative verdict, it at least makes it likely that Vance will face serious competition for the 2028 nomination.

Vance’s early bid to put some daylight between himself and Trump is his declaration that the Iran War caused the election loss. This has the additional benefit of not being very disloyal — Trump himself said the war was worth it even if it caused a huge loss — but it is surely an oversimplification of the Republicans’ problem.

Vance would likely represent a continuation of culturally conservative working-class populism as the animating spirit of the Republican Party. What other directions could the party take? 

Some of the obvious early candidates — former Vice President Mike Pence (R), for example — would represent a full or partial return to the old Bush-era Republicanism. He would have to overcome the very hostile attitude that many die-hard Trump supporters have for him, but he can argue that this election vindicates him to some degree. However, his personal branding as a muscular national security conservative might put Pence into the same lane as a candidate more attractive to Trump supporters, such as Secretary of State Marco Rubio (R).

There will also probably be an outright anti-Trump candidate in the mix. That could be Pence, but it could also be someone like Nikki Haley or  Chris Christie. The problem with that lane will be whether Republican voters really want to repudiate Trump after a bad election — they stuck with him after 2020, after all.

Some candidates will try to find a middle ground, warmly referencing Trump without necessarily giving him the full embrace. Rubio or exiting Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) could do this. DeSantis has a record of policy and political accomplishment to run on, without the foreign policy baggage — and he also has a demonstrated desire to run for the office. He is bolstered somewhat by this election, seeing how the Blue Tsunami pretty much missed his state. He can argue that he governed for durable change and did so successfully even in the worst-case scenario. Certainly, pundits expected to see races in Florida become competitive long before those in Texas, Kansas or Mississippi.

There will likely be many other Republicans interested in the position, as well, including former candidates. Unlike the Democrats in 2014 — whose bench was cleared so throroughly that there was no viable alternative to Hillary Clinton — Republicans in 2026 did not lose many candidates who could have been considered viable presidential aspirants. 

Silver linings of 2026

One thing a huge wave shows you is that anything that survives it must be well-built and standing on firm ground. That is where Republicans will have to start as they rebuild.

Everyone who frequents the Internet is already familiar with the hilarious AI-generated “Blue Tsunami” parody of the comedic television show “The Office.” A panicked Michael Scott, the manager, alerts the office that the Blue Tsunami means everyone needs an emergency diversity session, stat, so that they avoid getting canceled. Land acknowledgements, pronouns, transgender flags, blue hair-dye, nose-piercings, and all manner of other woke hilarity follows.

And of course, this parody is still funny, for good reason. The point is that although Democrats have gained a pretty strong hold on power in Washington and in the states, that doesn’t mean the country wants a new woke era. Wokeness is still funny because it is so tiresome and silly, and we’re not going back to a period where people are afraid to say so..

In fact, the very same voters who were voting overwhelmingly for Democrats — rejecting the Trump-era Republican Party in some cases by vast double-digit margins — voted for some pretty anti-woke ballot measures, in some cases by even wider margins. 

This probably comes as little consolation for those Republicans defenestrated in the recent wave. And it also won’t solve all the problems the nation will suffer after the vote just taken — Democrats are already looking for ways to override the voters’ will in some states. But it does provide some needed perspective about how to read the result.

America doesn’t need to go into a Woke 2.0 era — and in fact every reasonable person is on firm ground rejecting and ridiculing such a thing.

Ballot referenda: As in 2020, when they simultaneously backed Joe Biden overwhelmingly and also rejected DEI quotas for hiring and university admissions, California voters showed some level of common sense in 2026. Yes, their state is terminally Blue, and the Democrats’ candidate for governor won by 31 points. But they also rejected a 5 percent wealth tax on billionaires. 

Perhaps the narrow margin of this vote will alarm some rich people into moving. Only 52 percent of voters rejected the tax, which was supposed to apply retroactively to any rich person who lived in California as of Jan. 1, 2026. But at the same time, the tax did fail, and the opposing referendum — Proposition 42, a state constitutional amendment banning new wealth taxes — succeeded. And bear in mind, this vote took place amid the Blue Tsunami — highest Democratic turnout and the most depressed Republican turnout in generations. 

Other referenda limiting tax increases or lowering taxes succeeded in Florida, Tennessee, Wisconsin, and North Carolina. Iowa voters amended their state constitution to require a two-thirds vote for certain tax-increases.

Not all tax-related referenda went conservatives’ way — for example, Washington voters kept their new income tax, and Colorado voters scrapped their flat tax for a graduated tax with higher marginal rates.

Ballot integrity: Another area where voters’ support for Democrats did not prevent the advancement of conservative policy priorities was election integrity. For example, amid a statewide bloodbath for Republicans, Ohio voters added voter ID to their state constitution with more than 65 percent support. North Carolina and Nevada voters, who also handed victories to Democratic candidates on Election Day, also passed voter ID measures by very large margins. 

Not all such measures succeeded — California voters soundly rejected Proposition 39.

‘Gender identity’: In Washington State, for example, despite deliberately misleading ballot language cooked up by liberal state officials, voters overwhelmingly voted to save women’s sports from male athletes.

The vote on that was closer in Colorado, but the referendum did pass, even as the Democratic nominee for governor was winning his statewide election by 28 points. So did Colorado’s referendum banning gender identity surgeries on children. 

In Arizona, where Gov. Katie Hobbs (D) won re-election in a double-digit blowout, the referendum to protect women’s sports won with a higher share of the vote than she did. And although the Nebraska Senate and governor races were uncomfortably close, the vote on protecting women’s sports from male athletes was not.

So why did this bit of common sense not transfer to rejection of Democratic candidates who lack the courage to say no? First, voters had other considerations at top of mind. And importantly, most Democratic candidates are not as kind as Kamala Harris (D) was — which is to say, most are not willing to explain on camera — in an interview with a man pretending unconvincingly to be a woman — that they want hardworking taxpayers to fund sex-change surgeries for prison inmates who have been confined for preying upon other people.

It is also worth noting that a few noteworthy Democratic candidates ran away from the approved position on transgenderism this year — none of the ones who did suffered any electoral consequences. This should serve as a lesson for Democrats, but also for Republicans. Democrats can reject the craziness and survive. Republicans, meanwhile, cannot view transgenderism as a silver bullet for the Republican Party. Yes, the Trump campaign got great results by advertising heavily about it in 2024, but fewer and fewer Democrats will not be so dumb about this going forward as Harris was. And even far-left statewide electorates, like in Washington, can overwhelmingly reject the idea that a man can become a woman while also rejecting Republican politicians. Yes, this issue is a plus in your column, but don’t count on it to make up for your party’s and your candidates’ serious shortcomings.

Next week: A house divided: What does governing look like in 2027?